The reputations are in no special order other than each character having their own Category since you can go to each person at any point in each Chapter.
Anna Shultz
Meeting The Crew
- Look Away
- Insist
- Maybe I want to keep you company.
- Stop frowning, you’ll get wrinkles!
- I’m here with a surprise inspection. Report to me!
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- I was a notorious thief. + Rep with Anna – Rep with Lauren
- I was a generous lover. + Rep with Lauren – Rep with Anna
- Read the Note from your inventory +Rep with Anna, – Rep with Olivia
- Do not read the note and give it to Olivia. + Rep with Olivia
- I’m sorry
- I’m the captain here
- I was chasing someone
- Kill the prisoners +rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Behind The Locked Door
- My decisions are not discussed. (Requires 4 hearts)
- According to the code
Stranded
If you Praise her outfit
- Can you show me what’s underneath? (requires 3 hearts)
- Yes
- It’s just a joke
- Can I try it on?
- You’re wonderful in it
Stranded Day 3
- Take Olivia’s side +rep Olivia -rep Anna
- Take Anna’s side +rep Anna -rep Olivia
- The treasure will not be shared
Benno
Meeting The Crew
- So you had no motivation? (No rep, but seemed like the better option)
- This is the first time I’m talking to a real assassin!
- Small, but dashing!
- What are you cooking? Nothing poisonous, I hope?
- The top drawers are a bit too high for you, aren’t they?
- The chef is an important member of any crew.
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
After searching Annas room, go to the Hold (do not go upstairs yet)
- Continue talking.
- Skip the conversation
- Kill the prisoners +Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Behind The Locked Door
- I never got to taste your chicken
Stranded
- It suits you!
- It’s so unlike you!
Billy Graves
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- Kill the prisoners +rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Behind The Locked Door
When telling Billy that the Elf will join the crew for a while
- The Code
- My personal judgement
Dark Elf
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- Inspect her
- Leave her be
- Continue
- Stop
- To know you better (no rep but seemed like the better option)
- To learn your capabilities
- Answer my question
Stranded
- Watch
- Leave
Stranded Day 2
- Suggest a yellow inflorescence
- Suggest a dried root
- Suggest a blue bottle
- During the Celebration Party at night if you choose to bite the Dark Elf and say yes to allowing her to bite you, you will get +rep
Ethan Huskins
Meeting The Crew
- Throw him overboard.
- Make him a small ship and send him away.
- Decide when we catch him.
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- Kill the prisoners +rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Lauren Finn
Meeting The Crew
- You can’t scare me!
- I will try to study everything here…
- If I am to die, then I hope it’ll be beside someone like you.
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- I was a notorious thief. + Rep with Anna – Rep with Lauren
- I was a generous lover. + Rep with Lauren – Rep with Anna
- How may I help you?
- You should learn to knock
- Ask to stay (doesn’t give rep, but gives a bonus scene)
- Allow to leave
Ask her How do you feel?
- I’m single
- There is one girl
- None of your business
- Kill the prisoners +rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Stranded
When you Praise her outfit
- Yes
- No
- Quest to get her the rum
Stranded Day 3
- Invite her in (2 Hearts required)
- Remain Silent
Olivia Brown
Meeting The Crew
- I am not a murderer!
- Poisoning… This is not my way.
- You just need to poison me. *
- Come to my cabin later and I’ll show you!
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- Read the Note from your inventory +Rep with Anna, – Rep with Olivia
- Do not read the note and give it to Olivia. + Rep with Olivia
- Mention her pledge.
- Stay
- Leave
Ask her About your documents
- Yes, I will!
- No, I wont!
- Kill the prisoners +rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Behind The Locked Door
- It was a pleasure
- Blame it on poor eyesight
- How about Dinner with the Captain (Requires 3 Hearts) (opens up +rep options)
- Very pretty
- No match for you
- Her position is more important
- Dancer
- Animal trainer
- Acrobat
- Illusionist
Stranded Day 2
Asking Olivia What talents do you have?
- Agree
- Refuse
During the Never Have I Ever game when Olivia asks I’ve never pictured us making love…
- True
- False
- Take Olivia’s side +rep Olivia -rep Anna
- Take Anna’s side +rep Anna – rep Olivia
- The treasure will not be shared
Phillip Shultz
Meeting The Crew
- As your captain I demand subordination!
- Someone dropped his sense of humor. Not yours?
- Let’s put aside our differences and find a common ground.
Kvilleten + Leaving on Ship
- Kill the prisoners +rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren, -Rep Ethan, Benno
- Release the prisoners +Rep Ethan, Benno -Rep Anna, Phillip, Billy, Lauren
- Seize the cargo -Rep EVERYONE
- Sink the cargo (no rep)
Behind The Locked Door
When asking about the battle
- I switched off for a while
- Number of vanquished